Gusto vs Timetastic Comparison: Reviews, Features, Pricing & Alternatives in 2026

Detailed side-by-side comparison to help you choose the right solution for your team

Updated May 2026 8 min read

Gusto

0.0 (0 reviews)

Gusto is an all-in-one HR platform that automates payroll, manages employee benefits, and streamlines hiring and onboarding processes for small to medium-sized businesses looking to simplify their people operations.

Starting at $40/mo
Free Trial NO FREE TRIAL
VS

Timetastic

0.0 (0 reviews)

Timetastic is a digital staff leave planner that replaces messy spreadsheets and paper forms with a simple, automated system for tracking vacations, sick leave, and team absences.

Starting at $1.3/mo
Free Trial 31 days

Quick Comparison

Feature Gusto Timetastic
Website gusto.com timetastic.com
Pricing Model Subscription Subscription
Starting Price $40/month $1.3/month
FREE Trial ✘ No free trial ✓ 31 days free trial
Free Plan ✘ No free plan ✘ No free plan
Product Demo ✓ Request demo here ✘ No product demo
Deployment saas mobile cloud mobile
Integrations QuickBooks Online Xero FreshBooks TSheets When I Work Trainual Clover Expensify Asana Slack Slack Microsoft Teams Google Calendar Outlook iCal Active Directory
Target Users small-business mid-market small-business mid-market
Target Industries
Customer Count 0 0
Founded Year 2011 2014
Headquarters San Francisco, USA Manchester, UK

Overview

G

Gusto

Gusto simplifies how you manage your team by bringing payroll, benefits, and HR into one intuitive platform. You can run payroll in just a few clicks, with all local, state, and federal tax filings handled automatically. Beyond just payments, the platform helps you support your team with health insurance, 401(k) plans, and workers' compensation, all integrated directly into your payroll workflow to ensure compliance and accuracy.

You can also streamline your entire employee lifecycle from recruitment to offboarding. Use the platform to send offer letters, conduct digital onboarding, and track time and attendance without switching between different tools. Whether you are hiring your first employee or managing a growing team across multiple states, you get the tools you need to stay organized and compliant while focusing on growing your business.

strtoupper($product2['name'][0])

Timetastic

Timetastic is a dedicated leave management tool designed to strip away the complexity of tracking time off. Instead of chasing paper forms or updating manual spreadsheets, you get a central wall chart that shows exactly who is in and who is out at a glance. You can manage holiday requests, track sick leave, and monitor various absence types through a clean, visual interface that updates in real-time for the whole team.

The platform automates the tedious parts of HR by calculating remaining balances and sending instant notifications to managers for approval. You can integrate your leave calendar with the tools you already use daily, ensuring everyone stays informed without extra effort. It is built specifically for small to medium-sized businesses that want a professional, paperless way to handle staff leave without the overhead of a full HR suite.

Overview

G

Gusto Features

  • Automated Payroll Run payroll in minutes with automatic tax calculations and filings for all 50 U.S. states.
  • Benefits Administration Sync medical, dental, and vision plans directly with your payroll for seamless premium deductions and enrollment.
  • Digital Onboarding Send offer letters and collect signed documents electronically so your new hires are ready on day one.
  • Time Tracking Track employee hours and PTO requests that automatically sync with your payroll to eliminate manual data entry.
  • Compliance Alerts Stay ahead of changing labor laws with automated notifications and access to certified HR experts for guidance.
  • Employee Self-Service Give your team their own portal to download paystubs, view tax forms, and manage their personal information.
strtoupper($product2['name'][0])

Timetastic Features

  • Visual Wall Chart. See your entire team's availability on one screen so you can spot potential staffing gaps before they happen.
  • Instant Notifications. Receive leave requests via email or Slack and approve them with a single click to keep workflows moving.
  • Automatic Calculations. Track annual allowances automatically as you book time off, giving you and your employees instant visibility into remaining days.
  • Calendar Sync. Sync your approved leave directly to Google Calendar, Outlook, or iCal so your personal schedule stays up to date.
  • Burnout Board. Identify team members who haven't taken a break recently so you can proactively encourage wellbeing and prevent exhaustion.
  • Mobile App. Book and approve leave requests on the go with native iOS and Android apps designed for quick access.

Pricing Comparison

G

Gusto Pricing

Simple
$40
  • Full-service payroll for one state
  • Employee self-service profiles
  • Basic hiring and onboarding tools
  • Gusto wallet mobile app
  • Standard payroll reports
  • Workers' comp administration
T

Timetastic Pricing

Business
$1.3
  • Unlimited users and departments
  • Mobile app for iOS and Android
  • Calendar integrations
  • Approval workflows
  • Annual allowance tracking
  • Burnout board insights

Pros & Cons

M

Gusto

Pros

  • Extremely intuitive interface that requires almost no training
  • Automated tax filings save hours of manual work
  • Seamless integration between payroll and employee benefits
  • Helpful automated reminders for important compliance deadlines

Cons

  • Customer support response times can be slow during peak seasons
  • State tax registration assistance is limited for new businesses
  • Advanced HR features require the most expensive plan
A

Timetastic

Pros

  • Extremely simple and intuitive interface for all users
  • Generous 31-day free trial with full feature access
  • Seamless integration with Slack and Microsoft Teams
  • Affordable per-user pricing ideal for growing businesses

Cons

  • Limited functionality for complex shift patterns
  • No forever-free plan for very small teams
  • Reporting can feel basic for enterprise needs
x

Please claim profile in order to edit product details and view analytics. Provide your work email address to receive a verification link.

x

Please login in order to edit product details and view analytics.