Tithe.ly Review: Simplify Digital Giving & Church Operations for Churches

Managing church giving shouldn’t be this complicated.

If you’re researching Tithe.ly, you’ve likely spent too many hours juggling separate tools for donations, communications, and member engagement.

Let’s be real—the constant app switching is exhausting. It means key giving data slips through the cracks, and you waste time on manual reports instead of real ministry.

Tithe.ly sets itself apart by bringing online giving, church management, custom apps, and website tools together in a single platform that just works. I’ve analyzed how these tools sync—including how data from donations and events flows right into your people records and communication channels.

In this review, I’ll break down exactly how Tithe.ly can help you simplify your daily workflow to focus more on your congregation and less on busywork.

You’ll find out, in this Tithe.ly review, how it stacks up against similar solutions, what you get (and don’t), real pricing, and if it truly fits your needs.

Read on for insights and the features you need to make a confident decision—without the church tech headache.

Let’s dive into the analysis.

Tithe.ly Overview

Tithe.ly started in 2015 with a clear mission to help churches increase generosity and engagement. From their Nashville headquarters, they build practical digital tools for the unique challenges of modern ministry.

They specifically serve churches seeking an affordable all-in-one platform. I see them as a great fit for leaders who want to avoid vendor sprawl, as their goal is to bundle everything you need from giving to a complete ChMS.

Their acquisitions of Breeze and Elvanto were smart. Through this Tithe.ly review, you’ll see how this move strengthens their core church management (ChMS) capabilities, making daily operations easier for your team.

Unlike competitors like Planning Center that sell pricey modular tools, Tithe.ly bets on a unified suite. I find their biggest advantage is a predictable, all-inclusive pricing model that eliminates financial guesswork for your annual budget.

They now support over 37,000 churches globally, from small community parishes to large multi-campus organizations. This impressive scale gives me confidence in their ability to support your ministry’s future growth.

Their strategy is about making comprehensive tech truly accessible. They understand that ministry leaders are tired of juggling expensive, disconnected systems and want a solution that simply works together from day one.

Now, let’s examine their core capabilities.

Tithe.ly Features

Tired of juggling disconnected church software?

Tithe.ly features offer an integrated solution suite that simplifies church operations and boosts engagement. Here are the five main Tithe.ly features that transform how your ministry functions.

1. Digital Giving Platform

Are donation methods scattered and inefficient?

Managing various giving channels can be a headache, leading to missed donations and cumbersome tracking for your team.

Tithe.ly’s Digital Giving Platform unifies all donation methods, from mobile apps to text-to-give and online forms. I found the recurring gift setup and Apple Pay integration incredibly user-friendly for donors. This feature simplifies the entire giving process for your congregation and staff alike.

This means you can easily increase generosity and get consolidated giving data without the usual administrative hassle.

2. Church Management System (ChMS)

Struggling to keep track of your congregation?

Disorganized member data and manual administrative tasks can quickly overwhelm your church staff.

The Tithe.ly ChMS provides robust tools for managing people, groups, and communications, complete with volunteer scheduling. From my testing, the people database with advanced filtering is a standout feature for organizing your flock. It streamlines attendance tracking and targeted communication effortlessly.

So you can efficiently manage your congregation, freeing up time for ministry rather than endless spreadsheets.

3. Custom Church Apps

Is your church struggling to connect with members on the go?

A lack of a central mobile hub means your members might miss important updates and engagement opportunities.

Tithe.ly’s Custom Church Apps allow you to create a branded mobile hub that integrates giving, events, and sermons. What I love about this approach is how push notifications keep members informed instantly, something I found vital for engagement. This feature puts your church in their pocket.

The result is your congregation stays connected and engaged, accessing everything they need right from their phones.

4. Church Website Builder (Tithe.ly Sites)

Need a professional website without the technical headaches?

Building and maintaining an effective church website can be complex, often requiring specialized technical skills or high costs.

Tithe.ly Sites provides an intuitive website builder with unlimited storage and essential SEO capabilities, making it easy. This is where Tithe.ly shines, offering a solution where you don’t need to be a web developer to create a compelling online presence. It helps you share your message effectively.

This means you can establish a strong, professional online presence for your church with surprising ease and efficiency.

5. Messaging (Email & Text)

Is consistent communication a challenge for your church?

Fragmented messaging tools can lead to missed announcements and a disconnected congregation.

Tithe.ly offers integrated email and text messaging tools to keep your congregation consistently informed and engaged. From my testing, the ability to set up automated follow-ups for new visitors is a powerful and thoughtful touch. This feature ensures your messages reach the right people.

This allows you to maintain vital communication, fostering a more engaged and connected church community without extra tools.

These Tithe.ly features work together to create a comprehensive ecosystem for church operations, simplifying administration and amplifying your ministry’s impact.

Tithe.ly Pricing

What about your church budget?

Tithe.ly pricing offers transparent, tiered plans designed to give your church flexibility, from free giving options to a comprehensive all-access suite.

Plan	Price & Features
Free Giving Plan	Transaction Fees Apply (Donors can cover) • Credit/Debit (VISA, MC, Discover): 2.9% + $0.30 • American Express: 3.5% + $0.30 • ACH/Bank Transfer: 1% + $0.30 • Mobile app, online, text-to-give • Recurring gifts, Apple/Google Pay
All Access Plan	$119/month flat rate • Complete Giving Solution (incl. Text-to-Give) • Church Management System (ChMS) • Custom Church Apps & Website • Worship Planning • Unlimited admin users & member management
Individual Add-ons	Varies (e.g., ChMS $72/month) • Church Management System: $72/month • Mobile Church App: $89/month • Church Website: $19/month • Text-to-Give (standalone): $19/month • No long-term contracts, cancel anytime

1. Value Assessment

Real value for your ministry budget.

Tithe.ly’s All Access plan bundles a remarkable suite of tools, significantly reducing costs compared to purchasing them individually. What impressed me is how donors can cover transaction fees on the Free Giving Plan, often bringing effective processing rates under 1% for your church.

This means your church saves money while accessing powerful tools that might otherwise be out of budget.

2. Trial/Demo Options

Evaluate before you commit.

Tithe.ly offers a 30-day free trial for their All Access and Church Management plans, allowing you to thoroughly test features. You can also sign up for the giving tools completely free, which is great for exploring the platform without upfront pricing commitment.

This lets you experience the system and ensure it fits your needs before making a financial decision for your church.

3. Plan Comparison

Matching your church’s needs.

The Free Giving plan is perfect for churches focused solely on digital donations, leveraging donor-covered fees to minimize costs. However, the All Access plan provides immense value if your church needs a comprehensive solution, including ChMS, apps, and website, consolidating your tech spend efficiently.

This helps you match Tithe.ly pricing to your actual operational requirements, whether simple giving or full church management.

My Take: Tithe.ly’s pricing strategy offers strong flexibility, from a truly free giving option to a highly valuable bundled package, making it accessible for churches of all sizes.

The overall Tithe.ly pricing reflects transparent, flexible value designed for church budgets.

Tithe.ly Reviews

What do real users think?

My analysis of Tithe.ly reviews delves into actual customer feedback, providing a balanced perspective on user experiences, common praise, and frequent complaints.

1. Overall User Satisfaction

Users seem largely satisfied.

From my review analysis, Tithe.ly maintains a strong overall satisfaction rating of 94% on some platforms, averaging 4.4 stars based on hundreds of customer reviews. What I found in user feedback is how most users would readily recommend the platform, indicating general contentment with its capabilities and performance.

This suggests you can expect a highly positive experience overall with Tithe.ly.

2. Common Praise Points

Ease of use stands out.

Users consistently praise Tithe.ly’s intuitive interface and straightforward navigation, making it simple for both administrators and church members. From my review analysis, the multiple giving options are a huge win, catering to diverse donor preferences and simplifying the donation process for your congregation.

This means your church can boost engagement and simplify administrative tasks.

3. Frequent Complaints

Integration depth concerns emerge.

While Tithe.ly offers an integrated suite, some reviews point to less than seamless integration of acquired products. What stands out in customer feedback is how users express frustration over unfulfilled promises for future improvements, suggesting a potential “mission drift” away from user-centric focus.

These issues are generally not deal-breakers but are worth noting for future planning.

The overall Tithe.ly reviews reflect credible user satisfaction with practical feedback on integration and company focus.

Best Tithe.ly Alternatives

Considering your options beyond Tithe.ly?

The best Tithe.ly alternatives include several strong contenders, each tailored for different church sizes, specific needs, and budgetary considerations.

1. Pushpay

A more comprehensive solution for larger churches?

Pushpay is an excellent Tithe.ly alternative for larger churches needing robust community engagement and advanced ChMS features. From my competitive analysis, Pushpay offers faster fund availability and deeper control for complex organizational structures, though it typically involves a higher investment.

Choose Pushpay if your church is larger with a complex structure and a significant budget for premium features.

2. Planning Center

Need highly specialized operational control?

Planning Center excels with its modular approach, allowing churches to pick and choose specific products like detailed volunteer scheduling or worship planning. What I found comparing options is that Planning Center offers granular control for operations, but costs can accumulate as you add more modules, unlike Tithe.ly’s flat rate.

Consider this alternative when your church prioritizes specialized, in-depth management for specific areas over an all-in-one bundle.

3. Breeze ChMS

Prioritizing ease of use and exceptional support?

Breeze ChMS stands out for its straightforward, user-friendly interface and highly praised customer service, especially for small to mid-sized churches. Alternative-wise, Breeze offers strong ease of use and customer support, making it a simpler, focused ChMS option if you don’t require Tithe.ly’s broader integrated digital tools.

Choose Breeze if your primary need is a simple, intuitive ChMS with excellent support, without extensive integrated digital tools.

4. Subsplash

Is your church focused on media and streaming?

Subsplash is a strong Tithe.ly alternative if your church has a significant media presence, focusing on live streaming, media hosting, and custom mobile apps. From my competitive analysis, Subsplash excels in media and content delivery for sermons and content sharing, though its ChMS capabilities are less extensive than Tithe.ly’s.

Choose Subsplash when your church’s main priority is a robust media platform, including custom TV apps and advanced streaming.

The best Tithe.ly alternatives depend on your specific church’s size, budget, and operational focus.

Tithe.ly Setup

How complex is software implementation for your church?

This Tithe.ly review provides realistic insights into its deployment process. You’ll understand the time, resources, and potential challenges involved in getting the platform up and running for your organization.

1. Setup Complexity & Timeline

Starting small can be surprisingly quick.

For basic giving features, Tithe.ly implementation can take as little as five to ten minutes, especially for initial account setup. From my implementation analysis, more comprehensive plans involve a dedicated onboarding specialist for up to 60 days, indicating a commitment to structured deployment.

You should plan for a kick-off call and several one-on-one video training sessions, depending on your chosen plan and organizational size.

2. Technical Requirements & Integration

Minimal technical hurdles, strong integrations.

Tithe.ly is cloud-based, meaning your technical requirements are minimal; you won’t need new hardware or complex IT infrastructure. What I found about deployment is that it integrates well with popular ChMS platforms like Elvanto, Shelby Arena, and Church Community Builder, simplifying data flow.

You’ll want to prepare for data migration from your previous systems, which Tithe.ly supports via CSV imports for a smoother transition.

3. Training & Change Management

Intuitive design aids quick user adoption.

The platform boasts an easy learning curve, with staff and volunteers finding it intuitive and simple to navigate. From my analysis, the user-friendly design reduces extensive training needs, allowing your team to become proficient quickly without major roadblocks.

Expect less resistance to change due to the simplicity, but still plan for introductory sessions to ensure everyone understands the new workflows.

4. Support & Success Factors

Vendor support significantly eases the journey.

Tithe.ly’s support quality is consistently praised, with quick and thorough responses often including helpful videos. What I found about deployment is that responsive support is crucial for smooth operation and resolving any unforeseen issues during and after setup.

Your implementation success hinges on leveraging this strong support, actively participating in onboarding sessions, and dedicating time to data migration.

Overall, the Tithe.ly setup is generally straightforward, making it an accessible option for churches of varying technical capabilities; its intuitive nature supports successful adoption.

Bottom Line

Is Tithe.ly right for your church?

This Tithe.ly review shows a robust all-in-one platform for churches and ministries seeking to modernize operations, enhance engagement, and streamline giving processes efficiently.

1. Who This Works Best For

Churches and ministries of all sizes seeking an all-in-one solution.

Tithe.ly is ideal for church administrators, pastors, and finance teams looking to consolidate giving, member management, and communication into a single platform. What I found about target users is that churches aiming for transparent, predictable pricing will find exceptional value in its flat monthly rate.

You’ll succeed if your church prioritizes digital engagement, simplified financial tracking, and a unified administrative experience.

2. Overall Strengths

Comprehensive integration drives operational efficiency.

The software excels by providing a suite of integrated tools for digital giving, church management, custom apps, and website building, all within a user-friendly interface. From my comprehensive analysis, its predictable flat monthly rate stands out against competitors with complex, variable pricing models, simplifying budgeting for your church.

These strengths will translate into increased generosity and reduced administrative burden, freeing up your team for ministry focus.

3. Key Limitations

Deeper integration across acquired products needs refinement.

While Tithe.ly offers an integrated suite, some users note that acquired product integrations aren’t always seamless, and promises for future improvements can be slow to materialize. Based on this review, some integration depths remain a work in progress, requiring churches to sometimes adjust expectations or workarounds for specific functions.

These limitations are generally manageable, but they’re important considerations if your church requires hyper-specialized, deeply integrated solutions in every single module.

4. Final Recommendation

Tithe.ly receives a strong recommendation.

You should choose this software if your church needs a cost-effective, comprehensive platform to manage giving, people, and digital presence without sacrificing essential features. From my analysis, your church will benefit significantly if simplifying diverse technological needs under one roof is a top priority.

My confidence in this recommendation is high for most churches seeking a modern, integrated solution that delivers significant operational value.

This Tithe.ly review provides strong confidence for churches seeking an integrated, cost-effective solution to streamline their operations and enhance digital engagement.