LilyPond
LilyPond is an open-source music engraving program that uses a text-based input system to produce high-quality sheet music with the aesthetics of traditional hand-engraved scores.
MakeMusic Finale
MakeMusic Finale is a professional music notation software that allows composers, arrangers, and educators to create, edit, and print high-quality musical scores with complete control over every page element.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | LilyPond | MakeMusic Finale |
|---|---|---|
| Website | lilypond.org | makemusic.com |
| Pricing Model | Free | One_time |
| Starting Price | Free | $99/month |
| FREE Trial | ✘ No free trial | ✓ 30 days free trial |
| Free Plan | ✓ Has free plan | ✘ No free plan |
| Product Demo | ✘ No product demo | ✓ Request demo here |
| Deployment | ||
| Integrations | ||
| Target Users | ||
| Target Industries | ||
| Customer Count | 0 | 0 |
| Founded Year | 1996 | 1990 |
| Headquarters | null | Boulder, USA |
Overview
LilyPond
LilyPond is a powerful music engraving tool designed to produce sheet music that looks like it was handcrafted by traditional professionals. Unlike visual drag-and-drop editors, you use a text-based input language to describe the music, allowing the software to handle complex formatting and layout automatically. This approach ensures your scores remain consistent and beautiful without you having to manually tweak every note or beam.
You can integrate your music notation into text documents using LilyPond's specialized tools, making it a favorite for authors, researchers, and publishers. Because it relies on plain text files, you can easily track changes with version control systems or generate scores programmatically. It is a completely free, community-driven project that prioritizes typographical excellence over a graphical user interface.
MakeMusic Finale
MakeMusic Finale gives you the ultimate power to create any musical score you can imagine. Whether you are composing a simple lead sheet or a complex orchestral work, you can customize every aspect of your notation with surgical precision. The software adapts to your creative process, allowing you to enter notes via MIDI keyboards, computer mice, or even scanning existing sheet music.
You can produce publisher-quality scores that meet the highest professional standards. It solves the problem of rigid formatting by giving you total manual control over staff spacing, measure widths, and font styles. It is the industry standard for professional engravers, film composers, and music educators who need a tool that never says 'no' to a specific notation requirement.
Overview
LilyPond Features
- Automated Engraving Generate professional layouts automatically with built-in rules that mimic the spacing and aesthetics of traditional hand-engraved music.
- Text-Based Input Write your music in simple text files, making it easy to copy, paste, and manage your scores using any text editor.
- LaTeX Integration Embed musical examples directly into your books or academic papers using the LilyPond-book tool for seamless document creation.
- Extensible Scripting Customize every aspect of the engraving engine using the Scheme programming language to meet your specific notation requirements.
- Version Control Compatibility Track every change to your scores using Git or SVN since your music is stored in human-readable text formats.
- MIDI Export Listen to your compositions by generating MIDI files directly from your source code to check for errors and playback.
MakeMusic Finale Features
- Flexible Note Entry. Enter your music your way by playing a MIDI keyboard, using your mouse, or typing on your computer keyboard.
- Garritan Sound Library. Hear your compositions performed with stunning realism using a vast library of world-class sampled instrument sounds.
- MusicXML Support. Collaborate with others easily by importing and exporting files between different notation programs without losing your formatting.
- SmartMusic Integration. Share your music directly with students or performers through interactive practice tools to streamline the rehearsal process.
- Linked Parts. Edit your score and watch as your individual instrument parts update automatically, saving you hours of manual correction.
- Professional Engraving. Adjust every detail of your page layout, from hairpins and slurs to precise measure spacing and custom fonts.
Pricing Comparison
LilyPond Pricing
- Full engraving engine
- All supported notation styles
- LilyPond-book integration
- MIDI output support
- Access to source code
- Community-driven support
MakeMusic Finale Pricing
- Full professional feature set
- Complete Garritan sound library
- Unlimited staves and measures
- Standard technical support
- Two installations per user
- Everything in Full Version, plus:
- Discounted pricing for students
- Discounted pricing for educators
- Verification of status required
- Full professional functionality
Pros & Cons
LilyPond
Pros
- Produces the highest quality typographical output available
- Completely free and open-source forever
- Text files are lightweight and easy to archive
- Excellent for complex contemporary or early music notation
Cons
- Steep learning curve for non-programmers
- No native graphical user interface for editing
- Compiling large scores can be time-consuming
MakeMusic Finale
Pros
- Unmatched level of control over score aesthetics
- Industry standard for professional publishing and engraving
- Extensive library of high-quality playback sounds
- Powerful automation for managing linked instrumental parts
Cons
- Steep learning curve for new users
- Interface can feel dated compared to competitors
- Requires significant time to master advanced features