Square Payroll vs Toast

Detailed side-by-side comparison to help you choose the right solution for your team

Updated Mar 2026 8 min read

Square Payroll

Square Payroll is a full-service payroll software that automates tax filings, employee payments, and benefits management for small businesses using integrated time tracking and point-of-sale data.

0.0 (0 reviews)
Starting at --
Free Trial 14 days
VS

Toast

Toast is an all-in-one point of sale and restaurant management platform designed to help you streamline operations, increase sales, and create better guest experiences through integrated technology.

0.0 (0 reviews)
Starting at --
Free Trial 30 days

Quick Comparison

Feature Monday.com Asana
Starting Price $8/user/mo $10.99/user/mo
Free Plan ✓ Yes (2 seats) ✓ Yes (15 users)
Free Trial 14 days 30 days
Deployment Cloud-based Cloud-based
Mobile Apps ✓ iOS, Android ✓ iOS, Android
Integrations 200+ 100+
Gantt Charts ✓ Timeline view ✓ Timeline view
Automation ✓ Advanced ✓ Basic
Best For Visual teams, automation Task-focused teams

Overview

S

Square Payroll

<p>Square Payroll simplifies how you pay your team by automating the most complex parts of business ownership. You can pay employees and contractors in just a few clicks, whether they are hourly or salaried. The platform automatically calculates, files, and pays your federal and state payroll taxes, ensuring you stay compliant without manual paperwork. Because it integrates directly with Square POS, your team's hours sync automatically, eliminating the need for manual data entry or messy spreadsheets.</p> <p>You can manage everything from a single dashboard, including workers' compensation, health insurance, and 401(k) plans. The system supports flexible payment options like Instant Payments, allowing you to send funds to employees the same day they work. Whether you are running a single coffee shop or managing multiple retail locations, you get a straightforward tool that handles the back-office heavy lifting so you can focus on growing your business.</p>

strtoupper($product2['name'][0])

Toast

<p>Toast is a comprehensive restaurant management platform that centralizes your entire operation into one system. You can handle everything from front-of-house point of sale transactions to back-of-house kitchen displays and inventory tracking. Whether you run a small cafe, a busy full-service restaurant, or a multi-location franchise, you can customize the hardware and software to fit your specific service model and workflow.</p> <p>You can manage your staff with integrated payroll and scheduling tools while building guest loyalty through built-in marketing and rewards programs. The platform also enables you to expand your reach with online ordering and delivery integration, ensuring you never miss a sale. By putting all your data in one place, you can make faster, more informed decisions to grow your business and improve your bottom line.</p>

Pricing Comparison

M

Square Payroll Pricing

Free
$0
  • Up to 2 seats
  • Unlimited boards
  • 200+ templates
A

Toast Pricing

Free
$0
  • Up to 15 users
  • Unlimited tasks
  • List & Board views

Pros & Cons

M

Square Payroll

Pros

  • Highly visual and intuitive
  • Powerful automation
  • 200+ integrations
  • Great mobile apps

Cons

  • Can get expensive for larger teams
  • Free plan limited to 2 users
  • Learning curve for advanced features
A

Toast

Pros

  • Excellent task dependencies
  • Free plan supports 15 users
  • Strong reporting features
  • Great for enterprise teams

Cons

  • Higher starting price
  • Less visual than Monday.com
  • Fewer integrations

Related Articles